The Donny Cup Golf Tournament is a two team competition held annually at a location designated by one of its members. The order of who is to be responsible for the location and planning of the tournament is as follows:
| Anthony Scorsone | 2005 |
| Aaron Thomas | 2006 |
| Scott Kruppner | 2007 |
| Jason Curry | 2008 |
| Nathan Park | 2009 |
| Tommy Preston | 2010 |
| Brian Scorsone | 2011 |
| Matt McDonald | 2012 |
| Roger Least | 2013 |
| Keith Regan | 2014 |
| Todd Weidner | 2015 |
| Jason Weidner | 2016 |